Skip to content
P.A.V.E. article

Thanksgiving break: what to notice when your college freshman comes home

By Sue Hobbs, M.Ed. · Prepared

Thanksgiving break is not a report-card audit

There is a moment many parents know: your college student walks in the door, drops a bag on the floor and heads straight for the kitchen. You are glad to have them home. You may also be carrying a month of quiet questions. Are they going to class? Are assignments getting done? Are they making friends? Did that midterm grade mean more than they let on?

It can be tempting to use the first long meal together to get every answer. I would start somewhere else. Thanksgiving break can offer a clearer picture of how a student is doing, but the goal is to understand—not to conduct an inspection.

Look for patterns, not a single messy room or tired afternoon

A student who sleeps late on the first day home may simply be exhausted from a busy term. A student who avoids talking about classes may be looking for a break from the subject. Neither proves anything on its own. If you are concerned, be curious about patterns: are they regularly overwhelmed by deadlines, unsure how to ask for help, missing work despite understanding the material, or having trouble recovering after a difficult week?

Parents often learn more by asking what has felt manageable and what has felt heavy than by opening with grades. Give your student room to describe their experience before offering a fix.

Three conversations that may help

1. Start with what is going well: “What part of college feels easier now than it did in September?”

2. Ask about friction without blame: “Is there one part of managing your week that keeps taking more effort than you expected?”

3. Invite ownership: “If you could make one thing work better before finals, what would you choose?”

These questions are invitations, not a questionnaire to administer. You may ask one, listen and leave the rest for another moment. A student who feels heard is in a better position to name what they want help with.

Make the help fit the problem

If the difficulty is understanding chemistry or a writing assignment, the professor, teaching assistant or campus tutoring center may be a better first stop than private coaching. If the student needs disability-related academic adjustments, the campus accessibility office is the appropriate resource; high-school IEPs and 504 plans do not simply transfer into college unchanged. If there are health, safety or mental-health concerns, seek the appropriate qualified support.

Where a student understands the content but struggles to put commitments into view, start work, adjust a plan or follow through, executive function coaching may be worth exploring. Coaching is not a substitute for the other supports, and it cannot guarantee grades or fix a semester by itself.

A useful next step belongs to the student

A parent may be able to call every office and build every calendar, but doing that work for a college student can leave the underlying skill untouched. Ask what help your student would actually welcome. If they agree, they might choose to contact an academic adviser, check a syllabus, make a plan for one upcoming deadline or explore coaching. The action should be specific enough that they can explain it in their own words.

For students 18 and older, respect their role in choosing services and deciding what information to share. The aim is not to disappear as a parent; it is to stay connected without becoming the entire system.

When Thanksgiving brings a hard conversation

If you discover that the term is much harder than you knew, you do not have to solve it over one holiday weekend. Name the concern, ask what support the student wants, and agree on the next conversation. That can be more useful than a stack of new rules made in a moment of panic.

P.A.V.E. Support offers virtual, non-clinical executive function coaching for teens 13+ and young adults. Our free 30-minute discovery call is an opportunity to discuss whether that kind of support fits your student; individual coaching is a separate paid service. You can also read our existing article, “My college student is falling behind. How can I help without taking over?” at https://pavesupport.com/resources/college-student-falling-behind-what-next, or explore https://pavesupport.com/college and https://pavesupport.com/contact.

Related reading

Sources

  1. U.S. Department of Education, Office for Civil Rights, ‘Transition of Students With Disabilities to Postsecondary Education: A Guide for High School Educators’ (first published 2007, reprinted 2011). (opens in a new tab)